LB: The Pandora war seemed like a good idea in theory, but it didn't take long for me to get the sinking feeling that I was having a Bad Pandora Day. You know you've all had them - where you keep hitting "thumbs down" in total frustration. You want to say "Station, I thought you knew me, but it's clear we need to spend a lot more time together." I felt like I had a new puppy who I had taught lots of cool tricks to, but once we had guests over, he just sat there with a big grin on his face. Damn you, puppy!
Alas, I'm at least somewhat happy with the list. Glad that Arcade Fire is first, since after their Grammy performance last week there was so much talk on Twitter, etc. from people who had never heard of them. Really, America? You know Justin Bieber, but not Arcade Fire? Sigh. Not my favorite song from them, but glad they are representing.
Other mainstays that made it into the list: Wilco, Allman Bros & Ray (always). Not too shabby, but I'm concerned...
1. Arcade Fire–No Cars Go
2. The Postal Service – We Will Become Silhouettes
3. Wilco – Either Way
4. Allman Brothers Band – One Way Out
5. Devotchka– We're Gonna Make It
6. Yeah Yeah Yeahs –Runaway
7. Feist – Mushaboom
8. Johnny Cash – I Walk the Line (Live)
9. Ray Lamontagne – Empty
10. Regina Spektor – Hotel Song
11. Kid Cudi – Pursuit of Happiness
12. Vampire Weekend –Run
13. The Shins– Sea Legs
CW: Uh, that's it?
LB: You aren’t impressed? I do feel like we went for different genres.
CW: I'm totally underwhelmed. I could write three lists from mine that would work this list EVEN THOUGH you included three extra songs.
LB: I feel like 10 is SUPER short to represent a whole day of Pandora
CW: I'll let that fly because I feel sad for you.
LB: Plus for me, it’s sort of like when two B-list celebrities date, they become A-list material
CW: I don't follow and I disagree. Mine is gold. Wanna see what the hubbub is all about?
LB: Ugh. I guess so.
CW: First off, I'd like to say that this list is a result of hours of thumbs upping, thumbs downing and much toil with furrowed brow.
It started with two words that usually get you nowhere when you're looking for music: "The Band." It started with a little bit of Southern Rock, some Classic Rock. You know, the jams. But I sculpted it into an enigmatic, eclectic tour de force.
Hold on to your undies, this might get funky.
1. Jimi Hendrix– Like a Rolling Stone (Live at Monterey)
2. The Band & Bob Dylan– Knockin' On Heaven's Door (Live)
3. Neil Young– Old Man (Acoustic, Live)
4. Johnny Cash & June Carter-Cash– Jackson
5. The Kinks– Lola (Live)
6. Ray Charles– Georgia on my Mind
7. Joe Cocker– Something (Live)
8. Otis Redding– My Girl
9. John Lennon– Imagine
10. The Allman Brothers Band– Midnight Rider
Just in case you're curious, I could have put up three different lists–a studio song list, a live song list and a British band song list–that would have demolished your list.
LB: Well, I just don't think the lists are comparable. Seeing yours I don't feel as bad because they’re just totally different genres. It’s comparing apples and oranges.
CW: Better, different…po-tay-to, po-tah-to.
LB: I just gave up on Pandora after yesterday and a little today and have moved to Grooveshark, where every song is thoughtfully picked by yours truly.
CW: My Pandora could wipe the floor-a with your Pandora.
LB: I am a much better music aggregator than the robot algorithm that operates Pandora, so today is Grooveshark. I also feel like we can't compare stations
CW: Well, when you put it out there that you have the best Pandora station going, you kind of are.
LB: Well, yeah, But we have different taste.
CW: For true. Agree to disagree?
LB: When in Rome….?